Home > Themes > Emerging powers > Why Brazil has not criticised Russia over Crimea

Author

Oliver Stuenkel

Oliver Stuenkel is an assistant professor of international relations at the Getúlio Vargas Foundation in São Paulo, where he coordinates the School of History and Social Science. He is also a non-resident fellow at the Global Public Policy Institute in Berlin and a member of the Carnegie Rising...
More

Related publications

a A share Email print

Why Brazil has not criticised Russia over Crimea

Oliver Stuenkel , 27 May 2014

Emerging powers frequently stress the importance of sovereignty and the inviolability of international law. As a consequence, many Western observers expected that emerging powers such as Brazil would be quick to condemn Russia’s annexation of Crimea. Yet Brazil remained neutral and abstained from the UN General Assembly resolution that criticised Russia. Together with the other BRICS countries, it opposed suggestions to exclude Russia from the G-20, thus markedly reducing the effectiveness of Western attempts to isolate President Putin. Brazil’s unwillingness to criticise Russia may have less to do with its opinion on Russia’s annexation of Crimea per se and more to do with Brasília’s scepticism of Western attempts to turn Russia into an international pariah. From Brasilia’s perspective, pushing countries against the wall is rarely the most constructive approach. In addition, many in Brazil are wary of a global order that privileges the U.S. and allows it to flout many norms that apply to everyone else, arguing that these double standards are far more damaging to international order than any Russian policy. Finally, Russia annexed Crimea at a time when anti-Americanism around the world still runs high as a consequence of the NSA spying scandals, making alignment with U.S. positions politically costly at home.

Featured

Stay informed

Subscribe to notifications from NOREF.

Follow NOREF

Recommended

 
Yemen: Corruption, Capital Flight and Global Drivers of Conflict
Chatham House Report
Yemen: Corruption, Capital Flight and Global Drivers of Conflict
Chatham House Report
 
BBC
BBC
66,000 Syrians 'flee to Turkey'
66,000 Syrians 'flee to Turkey'
UK hostage's wife in appeal to IS
UK hostage's wife in appeal to IS
Yemen agrees truce with Houthis - UN
Yemen agrees truce with Houthis - UN
 
Al Jazeera
Al Jazeera
UN: Yemen's rival sides agree peace deal
UN: Yemen's rival sides agree peace deal
ISIL captive's wife pleads for his release
ISIL captive's wife pleads for his release
Ebola burial team attacked in Sierra Leone
Ebola burial team attacked in Sierra Leone
 
ISN
ISN
Informe Baja California
Informe Baja California
After "AfPak": Reframing Europe?s Pakistan policy
After "AfPak": Reframing Europe?s Pakistan policy
Multilateral Naval Diplomacy: Indo-Pacific Navies Exercising More Together?
Multilateral Naval Diplomacy: Indo-Pacific Navies Exercising More Together?